There seems to be a misconception about the kind of movie
that
Twisters is. On the surface, it looks and sounds like a sequel to
1996’s
Twister. The previews show tornados and people chasing said
tornados, just like in
Twister. The two main characters are a man and a
woman, just like in
Twisters. The title is just the first movie with an
extra S. But none of that makes
Twisters a sequel. It’s not even a
standalone sequel - set in the same universe, but with little or no narrative
connection - because you don’t get to claim “same universe” solely based on
setting
Twisters in Oklahoma.
(SPOILERS ahead, but only if you never saw Twister.)
It’s pretty obvious Twisters is actually a remake
of Twister, unfolding almost identically. Like all remakes that aren’t
shot-for-shot, some components have been tweaked or slightly rearranged. The
film opens like the original did - in the past - with our main character Kate
(Daisy Edgar-Jones), a young idealist intent on conquering the mystery of
tornados. Like Bill from the original movie, Kate has a magical ability to know
where tornados will show up and what they will do. She and her friends hope to
make a scientific breakthrough and attempt to dissipate a tornado with an
experimental chemical solution (which fails).
But it ends in tragedy at the hand of a massive tornado.

Flash forward just five years later to present day.
Instead of the tragedy driving her to fix her experiment and press on, we learn
that Kate took a desk job with NOAA in New York City. Inspiring, no? An old
friend Javi (Anthony Ramos) stops by to ask Kate to help him chase tornados in
order to...mumble, radar, mumble, something-or-other, help people, insurance(?),
mumble. Kate initially declines, but then changes her mind after Javi texts her
a bunch of stories of towns devastated by tornados. Inspiring, no?
Cut to Oklahoma, where storm chasers are gathering at a
rest stop (just like the first movie) and admiring the storm systems building
in the distance. They order drinks (just like in the first movie). Javi
introduces Kate to his team, a bunch of people in matching outfits and
vehicles. Wait a minute. In the first
movie, the group with matching outfits and shiny vehicles was the bad-guy team.
See what they did there? Kate’s on the bad-guy team, but *whispering* doesn’t
know it yet.
Then, riding in on a tornado-proofed truck comes Tyler
(Glen Powell). Tyler is a YouTuber and self-proclaimed Tornado Wrangler who records
himself doing dangerous stunts while storm chasing. Tyler is going to mug and
wink, then flirt with Kate until it’s time to chase a storm. Tyler is
accompanied by a motley crew of people in varied outfits and vehicles (just
like in the first movie), including a junky truck/RV. See what they did there?
Tyler’s on the good-guy team, but *whispering* doesn’t know it yet.
By this point in the movie, it’s painfully obvious that Twisters
is going to follow the same path as Twister. But just to make sure even
the people in the back get the message, here is how the rest of the film goes. Single
twister. Then sister twisters, where Tyler decides not to follow Kate and Kate
gets it right. Night twister, where Tyler and Kate rush a bunch of people from
their motel into a concrete pit to escape. Giant twister finale where kink is
worked out of the science thing from the beginning of the movie. Everyone got
it now? No?

Senior family member (Maura Tierney) owns cows and serves
steak (just like Aunt Meg in the first movie). A well-dressed ride-along person
(a reporter, in this case) in way over his head (like Dr. Melissa Reeves in the
first movie). Kate is a stuffy meteorologist who used to chase storms, has a
magical tornado spidey-sense, and reluctantly agrees to chase again (just like
Bill from the first movie). Edgar-Jones spends one day in a white tanktop with
the top of her jumper tied around her waist (just like Jo from #1). A theater
showing an old horror flick is torn up by a tornado just as a character is
uttering a famous line (The Shining in the first one, Frankenstein
in this one). Rescuing a dog from a house destroyed by a tornado (just like the
first movie). Everyone got it now? Good.
The problems with the film start with too many subplots
and no clear main plot. Where the first movie was all about getting the sensors
into a tornado in order to develop a better early warning system, the second
movie was about 3D imaging of a tornado to...do science stuff? Until it was
about taking advantage of uninsured people who just lost everything. Until it
was about finishing Kate’s college project to dissipate a tornado. Sprinkle in
some side-eye commentary about YouTube jackasses, and give us a lazy,
predictable romance and you have yourself a summer blockbuster. Except...

...they forgot the part about where good summer
blockbusters also have charm. Just because you cast Powell who practically
gushes charm, doesn’t mean that charm sticks to the movie. I’m looking at you,
supporting cast that was given nothing to do and no character development,
whatsoever. It’s not their fault that they aren’t Philip Seymour Hoffman, Alan
Ruck, or Cary Elwes. But the gang behind Tyler is very forgettable. They don’t
get a great breakfast scene with the palpable camaraderie of old friends. They
don’t get fantastic dialogue (“that’s the suck zone”) or memorable character
traits that make them humans (singing the theme from Oklahoma on an
adrenaline-stoked storm chase). They are just drone girl and guy who likes
rockets and I think there were a couple others there too, maybe?
Perhaps as big a problem is that the tornados are rarely
presented as dangerous. Tyler literally drives into multiple tornados, shooting
off fireworks into one of them. Many times, characters stand what looks like a
few yards away, just looking at the tornados. Then, juxtapose this with showing
us the devastation caused by a tornado (and Tyler and crew helping the victims)
and the viewer gets mental whiplash. Are these things dangerous or a clown
show? If we aren’t getting charm, at least give us a sense of danger and drama.
To be fair, the film does have one emotional moment -
when Kate breaks down in front of Tyler when he discovers her college project
in her mom’s barn. As with the rest of the film, this is just rehashing Helen
Hunt when she breaks down after the “jumper” tornado, but without the true
emotional weight and timing of Hunt’s scene. While Edgar-Jones sells it well,
it feels like it’s there to check a box rather than be an organic moment of
humanity.
Just like with Twister, the real draw of the film
is the visuals and the inarguable awesomeness of these storms. That’s why we’re
seeing this movie in the first place. As an action vehicle, Twisters
accomplishes its goal. We get plenty of gorgeously rendered tornados. We get
tornado chasing. We get loud noises and people running from tornados and
explosions and fire-nados and fireworks-nados and two gorgeous lead actors in
tight white shirts. Not good enough? Let’s dump water on them. There we go.
Rating: Ask for half your money back, but they can
keep the S.